*Note: If I assign this question, I might assign only a subset of the lettered parts.

Consider our dying hiker. Most students believe it is morally impermissible to charge him $1,000 for a bottle of water. (You have 1,000 bottles of water in your van and they were a gift from your mother.) In class, I covered four different ideas about what exactly is the nature of the wrongness. For the lettered parts below, I am looking for more than just a thin copying of lecture material. I would like you to deepen and elaborate your presentation of the argument, drawing on lecture, readings and your own thinking (on behalf of the person who believes it is morally impermissible to charge the hiker $1,000). I also ask you to present an objection to the arguments: You can think up your own objection or draw on the readings. Show me through your writing that you independently understand the arguments and the objections you present.