Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

Read and review the following fact pattern, and then answer the question presented using the IRAC System : The State of Maryland's legislature has passed

Read and review the following fact pattern, and then answer the question presented using the IRAC System:

The State of Maryland's legislature has passed the "Animal Product Labeling Act" ("APLA") and the Governor has signed the APLA into law. The APLA requires that any and all food products sold within the State of Maryland that contain all or any part of an animal (i.e., chickens, cows, and/or any other animal) must have a label on the product that clearly states (i) the type of animal in the food product (i.e., whether it is parts of a chicken, a cow, etc.), (ii) the specific part of that animal that is in the food product, (iii) the State and City where the animal was processed (i.e., slaughtered), and (iv) how the animal was slaughtered and killed for processing.

The Maryland legislature also included a provision in the APLA so that the APLA only applies to food products being imported into the State of Maryland and it does not apply to food products that are manufactured, processed and created solely within the State of Maryland and either sold within the State of Maryland or exported out of the State of Maryland. The label on food product must be clear and readable and have a font size of at least 12 font (so that everyone can read it and its not hidden as "fine print").

The Pambell Soup Company is a large corporation that manufactures and sells canned soup throughout the United States. Its sales of canned soup exceed 2 billion dollars. It manufactures its soup in the State of New Jersey and then imports its canned soup into the State of Maryland and other States. The Pambell Soup Company is obviously concerned about the APLA because it will increase the costs of its canned soup. Mainly,it will have to create a new label to put on the cans of soup and it will need special labels just for its canned soup imported and sold in the State of Maryland.

The Pambell Soup Company has filed suit in Federal Court, claiming that the APLA violates the US Constitution because the United States Congress has the right to regulate interstate commerce under the Commerce Clause of the US Constitution. In response, the State of Maryland states that the APLA is constitutional because Congress has not enacted any laws regarding the labeling requirements covered by the APLA and the State of Maryland has the right to regulate such matters under its reserved "police powers." The Pambell Soup Company disputes these claims and has noted that not only will the APLA cost it thousand of dollars in extra labeling costs, it will affect all other food producers that produce food products outside of the State of Maryland and import them into Maryland, and thus the APLA will have a significant impact on hundreds of businesses. In fact, the Pambell Soup Company has stated that if the APLA is upheld as being constitutional, it will stop selling soup in Maryland, and this will require it to lay off about 1,000 workers in its New Jersey manufacturing plant because of the loss of sales.

Using the IRAC system, please explain why you think the APLA is or is not constitutional - please keep in mind that I am more concerned with your analysis of the matter, rather than your ultimate conclusion. Also, in support of your position, you may add or assume facts (provided you state those added or assumed facts), but you may not delete the specific facts presented in the fact pattern.

2. Explain the difference between an appellate court and a trial court.

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image

Step: 3

blur-text-image

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

Intellectual Property Law

Authors: Tina Hart, Simon Clark, Linda Fazzani

6th Edition

0230366538, 978-0230366534

More Books

Students also viewed these Law questions

Question

What do you know of my (the interviewers) research program?

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

=+7. What is the big message you want them to know?

Answered: 1 week ago