Read the case below and answer the following questions.

Aintree University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust $($Respondent$)$ v James $($Appellant$)[2013]$ UKSC $67$

$1.$ Critically evaluate how the SupremeCourt arrived at its decision in this case. Support your discussion with evidence from the case including the interpretation of

statute, the use of precedent, and the approach to judicial reasoning. $(50\%)$