regarding that article: https://jme.bmj.com/content/medethics/47/9/595.full.pdf or It can be another article related to intellectual property issue that arose during the COVID-19 pandemic. Your IP issue can be a specific case study or a hypothetical example.

1- Brief description of the IP claim in COVID-19;

2. Identify and define the type of IP at stake;

3. Explain what are the potential positive and negative consequence for permitting IP in this claim;

4. Offer a rationale for permitting IP in this claim;

5. Critically reflect on whether we should permit IP for this claim.