Scott city nine and Marlene $40$ are married And both are appearance of these nine they are left together until Marlene moved out on October $1$ she stayed in home with Scott every night for the remainder of the year Marlene earned $42,000$ during the year and Scott earned $33,000$ Scott and Marlene file separate return all US citizen and all of season support is provided by both for his parents if each one try to claim sees as a dependent per the tiebreaker rule who is entitled to do so