Succesful and Unsuccessful counterexamples:

Consider the following argument and argument form Given Argument All violent video games are bad influences on children. And some violent video games are good social commentaries. Therefore, it follows that some good social commentaries are not bad influences on children, . ed Given Argument's Form P11 All Vare P21 Some Vare Some Gare not Below are three proposed counterexamples that purport to prove that the given argument's form is invalid. Determine the truth values of each sentence in the counterexample. Put a Tor" in the waces provided to indicate the truth value of each statement. Ther, based on these truth values indicate whether each proposed counterexample succeeds in proving that the given argument and its argument form are invalid. and Study Tools Truth Value? Offers P1: Proposed Counterexample A All Volkswagens are Beetles Some Volkswagens are German cars. Some German cars are not Volkswagens, P2: ptions C: uccess Tips Based on these truth values, is Proposed Counterexample A a successful counterexample to the given argument form? uccess Tips Yes No ole for a FREE 7- ngage Unlimited e Unlimited books or Free Truth Value? Proposed Counterexample P1: All velociraptors are dinosaurs. P2: Some velociraptors are carnivores. C: Some carnivores are not dinosaurs. more D Based on these truth values, is Proposed Counterexample B a successful counterexample to the given argument form? back Yes No Truth Value? P1: Proposed Counterexample C All minivans are vehicles. Some minivans are automobiles Some automobiles are not vehicles. P2: C: Based on these truth values, is Proposed Counterexample C a successful counterexample to the given argument form? Yes No