"The City of Lakeview adopts its budget on a basis of accounting that permits outstanding purchase commitments to be charged against the budget in the year that the goods are ordered instead of in the year they are received. During the year the city ordered and received $4,000 of supplies (of which $3,000 had been paid and $1,000 was unpaid) and had $500 of outstanding purchase commitments for supplies at year-end. In the budget-to-actual comparison, the expenditures for supplies would be:

" "$3,000 "

"$3,500 "

"$4,000 "

"$4,500 "