Question
The legislature of the of State A passed a new law requiring all drivers of any motorized vehicle to be 21 years of age or
The legislature of the of State A passed a new law requiring all drivers of any motorized vehicle to be 21 years of age or older in order to obtain a "Drivers License." The purpose of the law is to protect the safety motorists, because stats show over 51% of the car accidents reported in the State of A, involve drivers under 21. Drivers who have a driver's license issued by another state, with lesser age requirement, can't drive in State A.
A federal law prohibits employers from discriminating against employees on the basis of age.
Terry, who is 19 years old, applied for a job in State A, with employer/Comet as a driver which is a delivery company for interstate transportation of goods into other states, including State A.Terry would normally be hired to drive for Ajax's, headquartered Beta, but he cannot get a driver's license from State A. Terry would be able to pass the driving test requirements of State A but is barred solely because of his age.Terry has a driver's license issued by the state of Ohio qualifying him to drive.
Employer, Comet and Terry bring a lawsuit into United States District Court in the State of A against State A'sofficials to have the driving license law declared invalid.
1.What rights are given and protected under the US Constitution?
2.What are Employer's Comet's and Terry's arguments supporting claims that State A law is invalid and what should be the results? Discuss and remember to analyze the Commerce Clause, apply the analysis of 10thAmendment (health, safety and welfare of the people), Necessary and Proper, Dormant Commerce Clause-at issue must see a state law, does the state law enacted by the legislature infringe on interstate commerce?If yes...discuss the EXCEPTIONS i.e. (Market Participation, National Resources), if no, discuss the balance step, of state interest v. federal interest (State interest is health, safety, welfare of their citizens, local concern, rationally related or the federal interest is undue burden on interstate commerce, discriminatory in nature and lastly discuss the application of the alternative means doctrine.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access with AI-Powered Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started