These questions are based on the article, "The German economy: Clouds ahead", published by The Economist on June 7, 2014. See Attached.

ADVERTISEMENT Today Weekly edition Menu Search My account ADVERTISEMENT The German economy Finance & economics Jun 5th 2014 edition Clouds ahead Recent vigour hides underlying weaknesses in Europe's leading economy BERLIN AFTER months of procrastination, the European Central Bank acted on several fronts on June 5th to counter low inflation, currently just 0.5% in the euro zone. The ECB lowered its main lending rate from an already low 0.25% to 0.15%. More important, it became the first big central bank to resort to negative interest rates by lowering its deposit rate, paid to banks parking funds with it, from zero to minus 0.1%in effect charging them. Moreover, it announced new measures to help credit-starved businesses in the periphery of the euro zone by providing cheap long-term funding to banks supporting such firms through their lending. Such stimulus had become essential to promote a broader recovery that relies less on Germany. ADVERTISEMENT Buoyant German growth of 0.8% (or 3.3% at an annualised rate), reflected in Berlin by cranes on the skyline and roadworks at street level, was all that kept the economy of the euro area from contracting in the first quarter of 2014. Though that pace is likely to slow, Germany's economy is expected to expand by around 2% a year in both 2014 and 2015, easily outstripping the rest of the single-currency club, as it has done since the euro crisis started in 2010. ADVERTISEMENT Makers, not takers Germany's current-account surplus has averaged nearly 7% of GDP since 2006 and reached a new peak of 7.5% in 2013. Sustaining so big a surplus is all the more remarkable since Germany's main export market, the rest of the euro zone, has been so sickly; the surplus with other euro members has fallen from 4.5% of GDP in 2007 to 2.1% in 2013. But exporters have been adaptable, taking advantage of the hunger in high-investing emerging markets for the machinery and transport goods that German firms excel at producing. A humming labour market, helped by past far-reaching reforms, is another indication that things are going well. Employment last year reached nearly 42m, a rise of 3m in the past decade and the highest since unification in 1990. Unemployment has fallen from 11.4% of the labour force nine years ago to 5.2% now, a post-unification low and the second-lowest level in the 28-country EU. The surge in jobs has contributed to healthy tax revenues. A long period of ultralow long-term interest rates, in part due to Germany's status as a haven during the euro crisis, has also lowered borrowing costs on government debt. These favourable conditions, along with fiscal restraint, mean that German public finances have been blooming, too. In 2012 the overall budget balance edged into surplus and last year government debt fell below 80% of GDP for the first time since 2009. ADVERTISEMENT ADVERTISING Ads by Teads These economic and fiscal successes continue to make Germany a bastion of strength in the fragile euro zone. But the long-term outlook is worryingly weak. Although western Germany had a baby boom from the mid-1950s until the mid1960s, its birth rate has been below the replacement rate (of around 2.1) since the start of the 1970s. Net migration, though currently high at around 400,000 people a year, will not be enough to counter this demographic drag, which is reducing the potential for growth by crimping the labour supply. That makes higher productivity growth vital. Yet even if productivity improves substantially, the demographic pressure is such that potential economic growth will fall below 1% within a decade, according to the OECD (see chart). Raising productivity growth requires higher investment in both physical and human capital. Despite Germans' pride in their imposing current-account surplus, it can be interpreted as a sign of weakness, since it represents a shortfall of domestic investment in relation to national saving. Total investment has fallen from 21.5% of GDP in 2000 to 17.2% in 2013. The government is not only investing too little in new infrastructure but also spending too little on maintenance. The biggest decline in investment, however, has been from business. According to the DIW, an economic think-tank in Berlin, investment needs to be raised by around 3% of GDP permanently. Markus Kerber of the Federation of German Industry is especially worried about infrastructure, ranging from power grids to broadband. The shortfall in capital is human as well as physical. In Berlin, as elsewhere in Germany, employers report skills shortages in many industries. Spending on education is lower than it is in other rich countries, with only part of that gap warranted by the dwindling number of children. An OECD survey of working-age adults in rich countries found that Germans were a little more numerate than the average but a bit less literatea surprisingly poor result. The share of young people getting a tertiary qualification (such as a university degree) is less than a third, below the average for advanced countries. Higher productivity growth will require a better performance on the part of the services sector, which makes up 69% of the economy. It lacks the dynamism of Germany's manufacturers despite an encouraging surge in internet startups in Berlin. Reforms to enhance competition, especially among professional services, worth 10% of GDP, would help to gin up productivity more generally. The OECD advocates an array of reforms such as loosening the grip of notaries over commercial registration and the removal of regulated prices for the services of architects and building engineersa restrictive arrangement unique to Germany within the EU. But with things going so well, there is little appetite for a new wave of reforms. According to a recent poll by Eurobarometer, 84% of Germans are satisfied with the state of their economy, the highest share in the euro zone. The coalition government formed at the end of last year is too inclined to respond to the demand for payback after previous painful reforms, notes Michael Hther, head of IW Kln, an economic think-tank. A case in point is the recent backpedalling on pension reform, which will allow some people to retire with a full pension at 63 rather than 65. The resilience of the German economy should not be underestimated. But for the euro zone's good and its own, Germany cannot afford to become complacent. This article appeared in the Finance & economics section of the print edition under the headline "Clouds ahead" Reuse this content The Trust Project More from Finance & economics Buttonwood What if the dotcom boom and bust hadn't happened? The world's factory China's prodigious exporters have some new tricks Gains to diversification Economists grapple with their race problem The best of our journalism, hand-picked each day Sign up to our free daily newsletter, The Economist today Sign up now Subscribe Keep updated Published since September 1843 to take part in \"a severe contest between intelligence, which presses forward, and an unworthy, timid ignorance obstructing our progress.\" Apps & media Other publications The Economist The Economist Group The Economist apps 1843 Magazine About Economist Group GMAT Tutor Economist Films The World in Advertise The Economist Store GRE Tutor Podcasts The World If Press centre Careers Executive Jobs Which MBA? Executive Education Navigator Group subscriptions Help We use cookies to tailor your experience, measure site performance and present relevant oers and advertisements. By AcceptNewspaper Limited 2020. All rights reserved. Copyright The Economist Terms of Use Privacy Cookie Policy Manage Accessibility Slaverycan Statement clicking on 'Allow' or anyCookies content on this site, you agree Modern that cookies be placed. You can view our policies or manage Do Not Sell My Personal Information your cookies here