Question
This question is in regards to estoppel. Janice, a property developer based in Sydney, had long been seeking an opportunity to develop a block of
This question is in regards to estoppel.
Janice, a property developer based in Sydney, had long been seeking an opportunity to develop a block of flats in the inner-city suburb of Newtown. One day in early February, while walking along King Street, she noticed a "for sale" sign prominently displayed on a large vacant block. Janice had seen the block before and thought that it offered an excellent commercial opportunity, so she immediately called the number listed on the sign and reached Emily.
Janice and Emily spoke very briefly over the phone, agreeing to meet at a caf in Newtown on 8 February to discuss the land. Upon arrival at the caf, Janice and Emily had the following conversation:
Janice: Like I said on the phone, I've just been up on King Street and I've seen that the block of land is on the market. I have been interested in it for a long time. Are you handling that sale? Emily: I own that land. I'm looking to sell for around two million. I should let you know up-front that I don't want any lawyers involved in any sale. All they do is burn up our money, and I'm perfectly capable of selling a block of land by myself. Janice: Two million sounds like a great price, but I'm not sure about the idea of doing the sale without involving solicitors. Isn't there something that we might miss? This deal would be very important for my business - I'd want to build a pretty major development on the site on a tight time-frame, and I can't afford to let the sale go wrong. Emily: Look, cutting out the lawyers is one of the reasons the price can be as low as it is. It's up to you. If you're not comfortable doing this between ourselves, you can just walk away from this. But if you want to go ahead, we can shake on it and reach an agreement right now. I'll sell you the land for two million, and we can meet at the land titles office to finalise the sale two months from today. You really have nothing to worry about - you don't even have to bother with a deposit. Just pay me the full two million on settlement day. Janice: Ok, I'm sold. I'll see you at the land titles office at midday two months from today.
Janice and Emily then shook hands, exchanged phone numbers and email addresses, and went their separate ways. Janice, thrilled with the opportunity to finally build a block of flats in Newtown, subsequently arranged a significant loan from her bank to finance the planned project, using another project she was currently developing in Parramatta as the security for this loan. She also contacted an architect, and instructed him to prepare five sample designs for apartment blocks which might be suitable for an inner-city site. Janice paid the architect $25,000 as an up-front fee for these services.
A week before the day appointed for settlement, Janice sends an email to Emily in which she writes: "Dear Emily Just confirming our appointment at the Land Titles Office next week to finalise the sale of the Newtown block. Look forward to seeing you then. Janice."
Emily immediately replies also via email: "Dear Janice, thanks for the email. I have some news regarding the sale of the land, but I will meet you as we agreed to explain. Yours, Emily."
The following week on the appointed day, Janice arrives at the land titles office and is met by a very apologetic Emily, who explains that though she believed she was the owner of the King Street land - which had been in her family for many years - she discovered a month after her meeting with Janice that the registered owner is actually her estranged sister Patricia. Emily explains that she is very sorry, but she is unable to follow through on her agreement with Janice.
Advise Janice.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started