Question
Timothy Allen commissioned a custom motorcycle from Indy Route 66 Cycles, Inc., based inIndiana. Indy built it and issued a Certificate of Origin. Later, federal
Timothy Allen commissioned a custom motorcycle from Indy Route 66 Cycles, Inc., based inIndiana. Indy built it and issued a Certificate of Origin. Later, federal law enforcement officersarrested Allen on drug charges and seized the Indy-made cycle from the garage of Allens sisterTena. The government alleged that the cycle was subject to forfeiture as the proceeds of drugtrafficking. Indy filed a claim in a federal district court against the government. Indy argued that itowned the cycle, as evidenced by the Certificate of Origin, which the company still possessed.Indy claimed to have been keeping the cycle in storage. The government asserted that the cycle hadbeen delivered to Allen and filed a motion to strike.The court granted the motion to strike. Under UCC 2401(2)], title passes to the buyer at thetime and place at which the seller completes his performance with reference to the physical deliveryof the goods. Testimony by Indys former vice president Vince Ballard was inconclusive. Ballardimplied that Indy delivered the cycle to Allen and asserted that Indy kept it in storage. But the cyclewas found in Tena Allens garage. This strongly indicates that claimant delivered it to Allen. As in many cases, there may have been unstated reasons for the courts decision against Indy in thiscase. When asked whether Indy inquired into the occupations of its customers, the seller said no,because if it did, it would likely lose half of them. In response to queries about the price of Allenscustom cycle, Indy gave different answers at different times. The seller was also not clear on howmuch the buyer still owed on the price. When asked how long the cycle had been in storage, Indyprovided a date that fell after the cycle had been seized by law enforcement officers.
Suppose that Indy had given the Certificate of Origin to Allen and had kept the motorcycle. Wouldthe result have been different? Explain
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started