Tom and Granny are fighting over ownership of the family home. Since the two are unable to resolve their dispute amicably, Tom files a lawsuit against Granny in Federal District Court. At trial, both Tom and Granny present evidence that they want the jury to hear, but the judge determines that some old love letters between Granny and her late husband should not be presented to the jury. At the end of the trial, the jury determines that Tom is the rightful owner of the house, but the jury also determines that Granny has the right to continue living in the house until she dies.

(1) What can we infer about where Tom and Granny live?

(2) If Granny decides to appeal, what argument could Granny make in hopes of nullifying the decision of the jury?