Question
We reconsider the exchange economy from question 3 in Homework 5 to explore the possibility of price manipulation. Bruce and Sheila both consume the same
We reconsider the exchange economy from question 3 in Homework 5 to explore the possibility of price manipulation. Bruce and Sheila both consume the same goods (shrimp and Fosters) in a pure exchange economy. Bruce is originally endowed with 4 units of good 1 (shrimp) and 6 units of good 2 (Fosters). (As usual, think of both shrimp and Fosters as being infinitely divisible.) Sheila is originally endowed with 8 shrimp and 4 Fosters. They both have the utility function U (x1 , x2 ) = x1 x 3 2 . Let shrimp be the numeraire, so that p1 = 1. (a) Suppose the Walrasian auctioneer knows the utility functions of Bruce and Sheila, and calculates the equilibrium price on the basis of reported endowments. Suppose Bruce and Sheila honestly report their endowments to the Walrasian auctioneer. What price p2 will the auctioneer announce? Which consumer buys shrimp and which consumer sells shrimp (and how much)? [Hint: This is easy, and is just to get us started. If it is relevant, you may use the information from the solution to Homework 5.] (b) Suppose Sheila contemplates under-reporting her endowment of shrimp. What would be the resulting announcement of p2 by the auctioneer if Sheila were to report an endowment of 6 shrimp and 4 Fosters? (c) Suppose that Sheila must buy and sell the quantities implied by her endowment report. What will be her trades and final consumption of shrimp and Fosters when she reports an endowment of 6 shrimp and 4 Fosters? Which does Sheila prefer and why: reporting truthfully or under-reporting shrimp? (d) Suppose (just for this part) that Sheila does not need to buy and sell the quantities implied by her endowment report. Is it consistent with market clearing for Sheila to still believe that she can buy and sell as much as she would like at the announced prices? (e) Now consider the n-fold replica economy. In this economy, there are n clones of Bruce (with identical endowments and preferences), and n clones of Sheila (with identical endowments and preferences). Suppose all clones of Bruce and all clones of Sheila report their endowments truthfully. What price p2 does the auctioneer announce? (f ) Continuing with our analysis of the n-fold replica economy, suppose now that one clone of Sheila reports an endowment of 6 shrimp and 4 Fosters, while all other consumers announce truthfully. What is the resulting announcement of p2 by the auctioneer? What happens to this announcement as n gets arbitrarily large?
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started