What are the pros and cons of waiting for a year before deciding whether to invest? Ecsy-Cola18
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
What are the pros and cons of waiting for a year before deciding whether to invest?
Transcribed Image Text:
Ecsy-Cola18 Libby Flannery, the regional manager of Ecsy-Cola, the international soft drinks empire, was reviewing her investment plans for Central Asia. She had contemplated launching Ecsy- Cola in the ex-Soviet republic of Inglistan in 2004. This would involve a capital outlay of $20 million in 2004 to build a bottling plant and set up a distribution system there. Fixed costs (for manufacturing, distribution, and marketing) would then be $3 million per year from 2003 onward. This would be sufficient to make and sell 200 million liters per year-enough for every man, woman, and child in Inglistan to drink four bottles per week! But there would be few savings from building a smaller plant, and import tariffs and transport costs in the region would keep all production within national borders. The variable costs of production and distribution would be 12 cents per liter. Company policy requires a rate of return of 25 percent in nominal dollar terms, after local taxes but be- fore deducting any costs of financing. The sales revenue is forecasted to be 35 cents per liter. Bottling plants last almost forever, and all unit costs and revenues were expected to re- main constant in nominal terms. Tax would be payable at a rate of 30 percent, and under the Inglistan corporate tax code, capital expenditures can be written off on a straight-line basis over four years. All these inputs were reasonably clear. But Ms. Flannery racked her brain trying to fore- cast sales. Ecsy-Cola found that the "1-2-4" rule works in most new markets. Sales typically double in the second year, double again in the third year, and after that remain roughly con- stant. Libby's best guess was that, if she went ahead immediately, initial sales in Inglistan would be 12.5 million liters in 2005, ramping up to 50 million in 2007 and onward. Ms. Flannery also worried whether it would be better to wait a year. The soft drink market was developing rapidly in neighboring countries, and in a year's time she should have a much better idea whether Ecsy-Cola would be likely to catch on in Inglistan. If it didn't catch on and sales stalled below 20 million liters, a large investment probably would not be justified. Ms. Flannery had assumed that Ecsy-Cola's keen rival, Sparky-Cola, would not also enter the market. But last week she received a shock when in the lobby of the Kapitaliste Hotel she bumped into her opposite number at Sparky-Cola. Sparky-Cola would face costs similar to Ecsy-Cola. How would Sparky-Cola respond if Ecsy-Cola entered the market? Would it de- cide to enter also? If so, how would that affect the profitability of Ecsy-Cola's project? Ms. Flannery thought again about postponing investment for a year. Suppose Sparky-Cola was interested in the Inglistan market. Would that favor delay or immediate action? Maybe Ecsy-Cola should announce its plans before Sparky-Cola had a chance to develop its own pro- posals. It seemed that the Inglistan project was becoming more complicated by the day. Ecsy-Cola18 Libby Flannery, the regional manager of Ecsy-Cola, the international soft drinks empire, was reviewing her investment plans for Central Asia. She had contemplated launching Ecsy- Cola in the ex-Soviet republic of Inglistan in 2004. This would involve a capital outlay of $20 million in 2004 to build a bottling plant and set up a distribution system there. Fixed costs (for manufacturing, distribution, and marketing) would then be $3 million per year from 2003 onward. This would be sufficient to make and sell 200 million liters per year-enough for every man, woman, and child in Inglistan to drink four bottles per week! But there would be few savings from building a smaller plant, and import tariffs and transport costs in the region would keep all production within national borders. The variable costs of production and distribution would be 12 cents per liter. Company policy requires a rate of return of 25 percent in nominal dollar terms, after local taxes but be- fore deducting any costs of financing. The sales revenue is forecasted to be 35 cents per liter. Bottling plants last almost forever, and all unit costs and revenues were expected to re- main constant in nominal terms. Tax would be payable at a rate of 30 percent, and under the Inglistan corporate tax code, capital expenditures can be written off on a straight-line basis over four years. All these inputs were reasonably clear. But Ms. Flannery racked her brain trying to fore- cast sales. Ecsy-Cola found that the "1-2-4" rule works in most new markets. Sales typically double in the second year, double again in the third year, and after that remain roughly con- stant. Libby's best guess was that, if she went ahead immediately, initial sales in Inglistan would be 12.5 million liters in 2005, ramping up to 50 million in 2007 and onward. Ms. Flannery also worried whether it would be better to wait a year. The soft drink market was developing rapidly in neighboring countries, and in a year's time she should have a much better idea whether Ecsy-Cola would be likely to catch on in Inglistan. If it didn't catch on and sales stalled below 20 million liters, a large investment probably would not be justified. Ms. Flannery had assumed that Ecsy-Cola's keen rival, Sparky-Cola, would not also enter the market. But last week she received a shock when in the lobby of the Kapitaliste Hotel she bumped into her opposite number at Sparky-Cola. Sparky-Cola would face costs similar to Ecsy-Cola. How would Sparky-Cola respond if Ecsy-Cola entered the market? Would it de- cide to enter also? If so, how would that affect the profitability of Ecsy-Cola's project? Ms. Flannery thought again about postponing investment for a year. Suppose Sparky-Cola was interested in the Inglistan market. Would that favor delay or immediate action? Maybe Ecsy-Cola should announce its plans before Sparky-Cola had a chance to develop its own pro- posals. It seemed that the Inglistan project was becoming more complicated by the day.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Pros Company gets a better idea of the market demand by waiting and observing the market closely Com... View the full answer
Related Book For
Visualizing Environmental Science
ISBN: 978-1119147527
4th edition
Authors: Linda R. Berg, David M. Hassenzahl, Mary Catherine Hager
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
What are the pros and cons of using geothermal energy to produce electricity? What are the pros and cons of using tidal power to produce electricity?
-
What are the pros and cons of change? Does it help or hurt organizational performance? Do you like change? Why or why not?
-
What are the pros and cons of linking incentive pay to individual performance? How can organizations address the negatives?
-
Top executive officers of Preston Company, a merchandising firm, are preparing the next years budget. The controller has provided everyone with the current years projected income statement. Current...
-
Refer to Exercise 16.46. Income of people who have 10 years of education.
-
The Amplifying Manufacturing Co Ltd issued 300,000 of share capital for cash on 1 January 2004, the date of its incorporation. In the following two weeks it raised an additional 50,000 by way of a...
-
Select two perceptual distortions, briefly define them, and show how they can lead to poor decisions by managers.
-
Presented below are selected ledger accounts of Vu Corporation at December 31, 2014. Cash .................. $ 92,500 Merchandise inventory ........... 267,500 Sales .................. 2,137,500...
-
a. If seven people shake hands with one another exactly once, how many handshakes take place? b. Generalize the solution for n people. a. For seven people, there will be handshakes. (Simplify your...
-
Lakeland-Bering Aircraft Company is preparing a contract proposal to submit to the defense department for a new military aircraft, the X-300J jet fighter. Part of the proposal is a development and...
-
When giving an explanation for why an event happened, it is always important to: a. Be factual. b. Have documents to back up your explanation. c. Go over the explanation with a risk manager prior to...
-
Write a program that keeps reading integers from the user until he enters a negative number. The program should then display the following: Number of non-zero integers entered (excluding the sentinel...
-
The Moonloon coffee chain used to retail three types of coffee that sold for $12.00, $13.00 and $15.00 per pound. To simplify operations they decide to make a blend that they can sell for $14.00 per...
-
How does process modeling contribute to the optimization of complex industrial systems, and what methodologies are typically employed to represent and simulate these processes ?
-
T he ABC bank has a deposit base on which it holds excess reserves of $42 Million at a reserve rate that relates to a money multiplier (MM) of 5. On January 2, 2010, Mwen-Mwen, a customer of ABC bank...
-
There are multiple methods that can be used to determine a stock's intrinsic value. These can include utilizing such factors such as dividend streams, discounted cash flows, residual income,...
-
Speedy Auto Repairs uses a job-order costing system. The company's direct materials consist of replacement parts installed in customer vehicles, and its direct labour consists of the mechanics'...
-
A company has the following incomplete production budget data for the first quarter: In the previous December, ending inventory was 200 units, which was the minimum required, at 10% of projected...
-
Which international treaties aim to protect ocean resources?
-
How do conservation easements help protect privately owned rangelands?
-
How does per person energy consumption compare in highly developed and developing countries?
-
Why do shareholders in an acquired company agree to the dilution of their shareholdings after completion of the merger?
-
Why are the legal procedures related to mergers so onerous?
-
Where does the creation of value lie in a merger?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App