Examine and report on one of the many instances of a theory-practice debate in the field of technical communication. (See the list below for some possibilities-or locate another instance of a theory-practice argument.) Be sure to understand the context for the debate. What was the starting point for the debate (if one is identifiable)? What are the issues involved and the main points of contention? Who takes what positions in the debate and why? Evaluate the arguments that are being advanced. What are the claims of various sides? What evidence do advocates provide for their positions?

• The "Cruel Pies" debate in Technical Communication over the ethics of visual representation (Dragga and Voss 2001a, 2001b, 2003; Hayhoe 2002; Moore 2oo8; also see the letters to the editor regarding "Cruel Pies" in Technical Communication, vol. 48, no. 4, 2001, and vol. 49, no. 1, 2002 ).

• The debate in the journal of Technical Writing and Communication over the meaning and relevance of Aristotelian ethics to technical communication (Katz 1992, 1993, 2oo6; Moore 2004).