A group of 60 dentists work for a company that runs five offices. The dentists have been apportioned to the offices by the number of patients. Office A receives 14 dentists, Office B receives 11, Office C receives 11, Office \(D\) receives 12 , and Office \(E\) receives 12 . When a new dentist joins the group, the new apportionment gives the following: A 14, B 11, C 11, D 12, and E 13.

Determine whether the scenario violates the Alabama paradox. Justify your answer.