Question:
Take the actual SABR formula per Section 6.2.1 with σ0 = 0.5%, β = 0, ρ = −25%, ν = 30%, and F = 4%. By considering an expiry of 20 years and strikes at 10 basis points increments from 1 % to 2 % inclusive, try and construct an arbitrage involving butterflies (i.e. long a call at strike K − δ short two calls at strike K and long a call at strike K + δ where δ > 0). This is an illustration of the problem of negative densities under the SABR model for very low strikes and long enough expiry.
Section 6.2.1
Transcribed Image Text:
A major reason for the popularity of SABR is the existence of an
asymptotic expansion to find a good enough (for practical usage)
approximation for the implied volatility of a European call or put.
where
Initial Volatility (%)
Expiry / Tenor 2y 5y 10y 20y
3m
6.1 5.4 4.6
3.7
6.0 5.2 4.7
4.3
5.7 4.9 4.4
4.1
4.7 4.2 3.9
3.6
3.9 3.7 3.8
3.4
3.8 3.8 3.7 3.2
X
ly
2y
5y
+
10y
20y
Volatility of Volatility (%)
Expiry / Tenor 2y 5y 10y
3m
ly
2y
5y
10y
20y
ly
2y
5y
10y
20y
Blend 0.5
(FK)(1-3)/2 1 +
Correlation (%)
Expiry / Tenor 2y
3m
26
1+
(1 - 3)²
Specifically, given the current forward level F, the implied volatility
for an option with expiry T and strike K is
A(K,T) =
[(₁
24
1 ρβυσο
4 (FK)(1-3)/2
z =
V
σο
A(F,T) =
20y
79 62 67 94
49 40 40
x(z) = log
56 52 52
63 60 64
53 53 65 52
30 28 26 23
5y 10y 20y
-1 -29 -71
22
6 -12 -34
-10-24 -30
-17 -23 -30 -32
1
-21 -24-26 -27
-24-17-14 -15
σο
(1-3)² 2 F (1-3)4
log² +
24
1920
0²
(FK)¹-B
σο
F1-3
+
45 46 59
2-3p²
24
F
(FK)(¹-0)/2 log ¹ and
√1-2pz +z²+z-p
1+
2², ²] T +...}
For the case of an at-the-money option, this simplifies to
σο
A(F,T) = ¡{¹+
F1-B
1-p
1ρβνσο
+ +
4 F1-B
4 F
log ¹ K} (x(3))
-
24
F2-28
+ + ²] +}.
1ρβνσο
+
4 F1-8
2-3p²
24
For the case of an at-the-money option, this simplifies to
(1 - 3)² o
24 F2-23
2 - 30/²2, 2] T +... }.
24
Given the implied volatility, we can then use the Black-Scholes
formula to price European call or put options.
For the interested reader, the details of the perturbation methods
used to obtain the asymptotic expansion are best obtained from
the papers by Hagan and Woodward [HW99] and by Hagan et al.
[HKLW02]. The second paper also gives a very good intuition on the
workings of SABR.