Case 10-11

Eye Vision Inc.

Eye Vision Inc. (Eye Vision) has been in the business of manufacturing medical devices

for eye treatments for more than 20 years. Eye Vision enters into contractual

arrangements to sell its equipment to large hospitals and universities throughout the

United States. Eye Visions contractual arrangements also offer an initial option to

purchase a two-year separately priced maintenance agreement for the equipment. There

has been a significant increase in sales during the first quarter because of a surge in

interest in the Clear View Laser product.

Eye Vision has a December 31 fiscal year-end. In conjunction with the first quarter

review of the revenue line item for Eye Vision, the audit senior (Jason Doolittle)

completed the following procedures:

1. Reviewed the marketing brochure for Eye Visions product offerings, which

included a significant focus on the Clear View Laser.

2. Interviewed the vice president of sales.

3. Reviewed the clients memo supporting revenue recognition of its medical

equipment sales of the Clear View Laser.

4. Performed an analytical test of Eye Visions medical equipment sales based on

the increase in units sold compared to the prior quarter.

5. Read one of the standardized sales agreements for the Clear View Laser.

The following is a summary of the key facts identified by the audit senior:

MEMO

To: Eye Vision Audit Working Papers

From: Jason Doolittle, audit senior

Subject: Contract Review

Date: March 31, 2010

Eye Vision continues to perform research and development regarding additional eye

treatments that could be performed using the Clear View Laser. Eye Vision must receive

additional FDA approval for any new treatment applications. With FDA approval, Eye

Vision will offer, on a when-and-if available basis, new treatment applications for the

Clear View Laser through software updates that will be available at no charge to

customers who have purchased a maintenance agreement. Eye Vision has not provided

any specific details to its customers regarding future treatment applications that are still

under development.

On January 1, 2010, Eye Vision signed a contract with Holland Hospital to sell the Clear

View Laser. In addition to this medical equipment, the contract includes an initial option

to purchase a two-year separately priced maintenance agreement on the Clear View

Case 10-11: Eye Vision Inc. Page 2

Copyright 2008 Deloitte Development LLC

All Rights Reserved.

Laser. The maintenance plan includes telephone support, repair or replacement of

nonconforming parts, software updates, and bug fixes for the software. Holland Hospital

has elected to purchase the maintenance agreement. Eye Vision will receive $1 million

for the Clear View Laser and $200,000 up front for the two years of maintenance.

Eye Vision has never sold, nor does it offer to sell, the Clear View Laser without the

embedded software because the software is necessary to perform the medical procedures

for which the laser is intended.

The Eye Vision maintenance agreement is available only to purchasers of the Clear View

Laser and has never been sold separately. There is not a general right of return for sales

of the Clear View Laser.

Effective January 1, 2010, at the beginning of fiscal year 2010, Eye Vision has elected to

early adopt ASU 2009-13, Multiple-Deliverable Revenue Arrangements (formerly EITF

Issue No. 08-1, Revenue Arrangements With Multiple Deliverables), and ASU 2009-

14, Certain Revenue Arrangements That Include Software Elements (formerly EITF Issue

No. 09-3, Applicability of AICPA Statement of Position 97-2 to Certain Arrangements

That Include Software Elements), for all new or materially modified revenue

arrangements.

Required:

Apply each of the five step process for revenue recognition under ASC 606-10 to the case facts.

1. What is the contract?
2. Identify the performance obligations.
3. What is the selling price?
4. How or when revenue is recognized for each performance obligations?