Explain what arguments the plaintiff (Mr. Henderson) could raise to the court to substantiate his lawsuit against
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Explain what arguments the plaintiff (Mr. Henderson) could raise to the court to substantiate his lawsuit against the Condo Corporations.
2. Explain what arguments the defendant (Jefferson Property Manager for Condo Corporations) could raise to the court in their defense.
Transcribed Image Text:
Case: Henderson vs Jefferson Mr. Henderson ran a commercial property maintenance business. In 2015, his company concluded a contract with some condo corporations. The contract was for a number of services including clearing away snow and it lasted for two winters. The company made a new contract with the condo corporations in 2017. It was supposed to last two more winters. A clause in the contract stated if the condo corporations weren't happy with the performance of the services, they could end it for any reason. They just had to give ten days' notice to Mr. Henderson. In the winter of 2017 to 2018, some condo owners complained that snow wasn't always removed from their parking spots. Mr. Henderson attended a meeting to talk about the problem. The meeting went well. Everyone seemed happy enough. A few months later, the condo buildings hired a new property manager, Mr. Jefferson. Mr. Jefferson told the committee in charge of the contract that they should put an end to it before the next winter. The committee decided to end the contract, but no one told Mr. Henderson. Mr. Henderson thought everyone was happy with his services. People from the condo corporations talked to him and led him to believe that he would probably get another contract for more winters. He thought this was true. He also had a summer contract with the condo corporations. During the summer, he did extra maintenance work for free because he wanted to encourage them to renew the winter contract. In September 2018, the condo corporations told Mr. Henderson they were putting an end to the winter contract. They gave him ten days' notice. Mr. Henderson didn't think this was fair. It was too late for him to find a new contract for the winter. He said the condo corporations didn't live up to the terms of the contract. He argued that people who make contracts together can't lie to or mislead each other on purpose in doing what they have agreed to in the contract. Mr. Henderson sued the condo corporations. He asked the court for over $80,000. This was to cover breaking the contract, not being honest with him, and the extra services he gave the condo corporations for free. The condo corporations said they had lived up to the terms of the contract. Questions: 1. Explain what arguments the plaintiff (Mr. Henderson) could raise to the court to substantiate his lawsuit against the Condo Corporations. 2. Explain what arguments the defendant (Jefferson Property Manager for Condo Corporations) could raise to the court in their defense. 3. Propose an outcome to the case. Explain your rationale for the decision using the source of law applicable to the case. Include how you would decide on the awarding of damages in this case. Case: Henderson vs Jefferson Mr. Henderson ran a commercial property maintenance business. In 2015, his company concluded a contract with some condo corporations. The contract was for a number of services including clearing away snow and it lasted for two winters. The company made a new contract with the condo corporations in 2017. It was supposed to last two more winters. A clause in the contract stated if the condo corporations weren't happy with the performance of the services, they could end it for any reason. They just had to give ten days' notice to Mr. Henderson. In the winter of 2017 to 2018, some condo owners complained that snow wasn't always removed from their parking spots. Mr. Henderson attended a meeting to talk about the problem. The meeting went well. Everyone seemed happy enough. A few months later, the condo buildings hired a new property manager, Mr. Jefferson. Mr. Jefferson told the committee in charge of the contract that they should put an end to it before the next winter. The committee decided to end the contract, but no one told Mr. Henderson. Mr. Henderson thought everyone was happy with his services. People from the condo corporations talked to him and led him to believe that he would probably get another contract for more winters. He thought this was true. He also had a summer contract with the condo corporations. During the summer, he did extra maintenance work for free because he wanted to encourage them to renew the winter contract. In September 2018, the condo corporations told Mr. Henderson they were putting an end to the winter contract. They gave him ten days' notice. Mr. Henderson didn't think this was fair. It was too late for him to find a new contract for the winter. He said the condo corporations didn't live up to the terms of the contract. He argued that people who make contracts together can't lie to or mislead each other on purpose in doing what they have agreed to in the contract. Mr. Henderson sued the condo corporations. He asked the court for over $80,000. This was to cover breaking the contract, not being honest with him, and the extra services he gave the condo corporations for free. The condo corporations said they had lived up to the terms of the contract. Questions: 1. Explain what arguments the plaintiff (Mr. Henderson) could raise to the court to substantiate his lawsuit against the Condo Corporations. 2. Explain what arguments the defendant (Jefferson Property Manager for Condo Corporations) could raise to the court in their defense. 3. Propose an outcome to the case. Explain your rationale for the decision using the source of law applicable to the case. Include how you would decide on the awarding of damages in this case.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer 1 Arguments for the Plaintiff Mr Henderson a Breach of Contract Mr Henderson could argue that the condo corporations breached the contract by terminating it without valid cause and without prov... View the full answer
Related Book For
Smith and Roberson Business Law
ISBN: 978-0538473637
15th Edition
Authors: Richard A. Mann, Barry S. Roberts
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
T/F. In general, Automated Testing tools are not suitable when it comes to rigorous, repetitive and mundane tests in large volumes. T/F. A program is testable if there is no test oracle for the...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
In Problems 4358, (a) Find the vertex and the axis of symmetry of each quadratic function, and determine whether the graph is concave up or concave down. (b) Find the y-intercept and the...
-
Rewrite each exponential equation in logarithmic form using the definition of a logarithm. Then solve for x. (Give your answers rounded to four decimal places.) a. 10x = 0.001 b. 5x = 100 c. 35x = 8...
-
Does U.S. District Judge Dickran Tevrizian believe that Barry Minkow is reformed?
-
Use an Internet search engine to fi nd a Web site that compares the cost of living in cities in the United States. If you were offered a salary of $35,000 in Columbus, Ohio, what salary would you...
-
Fair Value Measurement Presented below is information related to the purchases of common stock by Lilly Company during 2010. (a) What entry would Lilly make at December 31, 2010, to record the...
-
17.At what nominal rate of interest c.m. does money double in 12 years? 7. A 2021 Yukon SUV, (from japan) averages $44,400 CAD. If the JPY drops in value against CAD by 6.0%, find the new cost in...
-
Please help me solve this problem! #23. on 23 A stock has a beta of 1.4 and an expected return of 14.6 percent. A risk-free asset is ed yielding 3.5 percent. You want to create a $20,000 portfolio...
-
His gross 2) David runs an illegal numbers racket. income was $500,000. He incurred the following expenses: Illegal kickbacks Salaries $20,000 80,000 Rent 24,000 Utilities and telephone 9,000 Bribes...
-
The subject is a 227,500 square foot (SF) distribution warehouse built in 2023. It is located in a privately developed industrial park with good highway access. 10% of the space is finished office....
-
An aluminum wing on a passenger jet is 37 m long when its temperature is 18C. At what temperature would the wing be 6 cm (0.06 m) shorter?
-
For each of the following, select its usual cost classification in an absorption costing system. Miscellaneous factory supplies ( oils , ?lubricants, etc. ) Shipping costs ( freight out ) Factory...
-
A very common example of base motion is the single-degree-of-freedom model of an automobile driving over a rough road. The road is modeled as providing a base motion displacement of y(t)=...
-
A snow insurance company offers an insurance contract that costs the buyer an upfront premium at the beginning of 2023. The contract specifies that if it snows more than 2 feet in CT on any single...
-
The column shown in the figure is fixed at the base and free at the upper end. A compressive load P acts at the top of the column with an eccentricity e from the axis of the column. Beginning with...
-
Bill Kinsey was charged with murdering his wife while working for the Peace Corps in Tanzania. After waiting six months in jail, he was acquitted at a trial that attracted wide publicity. Five years...
-
As part of a corporate plan to stimulate sagging television sales, GTE Sylvania began to phase out its wholesale distributors and began to sell its television sets directly to a smaller and more...
-
We consider the reach of the private right of action the Court has found implied in 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, [citation], and SEC Rule 10b5, [citation]. In this suit investors...
-
Let \(C\) be the positively oriented ellipse \(3 x^{2}+y^{2}=9\). Define \[F\left(z_{0} ight)=\int_{C} \frac{z^{2}+2 z}{z-z_{0}} d z\] Find \(F(2 i)\) and \(F(2)\). [Sketch the ellipse in the complex...
-
Show that for \(g\) and \(h\) analytic functions at \(z_{0}\), with \(g\left(z_{0} ight) eq 0, h\left(z_{0} ight)=0\), and \(h^{\prime}\left(z_{0} ight) eq 0\),...
-
Show that \[\int_{C} \frac{d z}{(z-1-i)^{n+1}}=\left\{\begin{array}{cc} 0, & n eq 0 \\ 2 \pi i, & n=0 \end{array} ight.\] for \(C\) the boundary of the square \(0 \leq x \leq 2,0 \leq y \leq 2\)...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App