Question
GeorgeLambertisthepresidentandCEOofSunsetBayOysterCompany(hereinafterreferredtoasSunset).SunsetisaCaliforniacorporationwhichhasitsmainoysterprocessingfacilitylocatedinPointReyes,California.Sunset'sfacilityinPointReyesislocatedinsidetheboundariesofPointReyesNationalSeashore(hereinafterreferredtoasPointReyes),anationalparkrunbytheUnitedStatesDepartmentofInterior.Overthepastfouryears,Sunsethasbeenverysuccessful.In2016,Sunset'soperationsbroughtinover$10millioninprofits. Sunset'ssuccessisduetoaleaseagreementbetweenitselfandPointReyes.Theleaseagreement,signedonMarch1,2014,byGeorgeLambertandAlbertJones,theSecretaryoftheInterior,allowedSunsettolease200acresofPointReyestooperateanoysterprocessingplant.TheleaseagreementallowedSunsettoleasethislandatalowrateforaperiodoffouryears(untilMarch1,2018),afterwhichthelandwouldrevertbacktoPointReyesforestablishmentofamarinewildernessarea.TheleaseagreementwastobenefitnotonlySunsetandPointReyesbutalsothelocalcommunity.Theleasehelpedtocreatethousandsofjobsintheareaandrevitalizedthelocaleconomy. However,atthetimetheleasewassignedonMarch1,2014,byMr.JonesandMr.Lambert,someverbalchangesweremadetotheleaseagreement.Specifically,Mr.JonesstatedtoMr.Lambertthefollowing:Look,thisleaseiseconomicallybeneficialforbothofus;sowhylimititto4years?Let'sextendtheleasetermto,say,10years.Howaboutit?Lambertagreedstating,Sure,I'mallforit.Let'sdo10years!Immediatelyafterthisconversation,bothmenshookhandsandsignedthelease.Buttheverbalagreementregardingthechangeintheleasetermfrom4yearsto10yearswasneverputinwriting. FromMarch1,2014,toJanuary4,2018,thingswentwellforSunset.Itmadesubstantialprofits,peoplewereemployed,andthelocaleconomyimproved.ButinlateDecember2017,localfishermannoticedthefishanddolphinpopulationsweredying.SomelocalenvironmentalistspicketedSunset'sfacility,blamingitforthedyingfishanddolphins.However,scientistshavebeenunabletofindanyevidencelinkingSunset'soperationstothedyingfishanddolphinpopulations. Despitelackofscientificevidence,localenvironmentalistsprotestedandtooktheircomplaintstoAlbertJones.Basedonthesecomplaints,Mr.JonesdecidedtopayasurprisevisittotheSunsetfacility.OnJanuary4,2017,Mr.JonesvisitedSunset'sfacilityinPointReyes.Withoutexplanation,heabruptlytoldMr.Lambert,Theleaseisup,it'sover,andyou'vegot10days-untilJanuary14 th -togetout.Shockedandangry,Mr.Lambertreplied,Youcan'tdothat!Theleaseisn'tup!Wehaveacontract! SunsetsubsequentlyfiledsuitinSuperiorCourtagainsttheDepartmentoftheInteriorforbreachoftheleaseagreement.Inaddition,SunsetwantstoofferMr.Lambert'stestimonyincourtregardingtheverbalchangesmadetothewrittenleaseagreement.Sunsethasalsorequestedaninjunctiontostalltheclosureofitsplant. Pleasediscusstheissuesinthiscase. Studentdiscusses 5correctissues clearlyandconcisely answer using the IRAC (issue, rule, application, conclusion) form
GeorgeLambertisthepresidentandCEOofSunsetBayOysterCompany(hereinafterreferredtoas"Sunset").SunsetisaCaliforniacorporationwhichhasitsmainoysterprocessingfacilitylocatedinPointReyes,California.Sunset'sfacilityinPointReyesislocatedinsidetheboundariesofPointReyesNationalSeashore(hereinafterreferredtoas"PointReyes"),anationalparkrunbytheUnitedStatesDepartmentofInterior.Overthepastfouryears,Sunsethasbeenverysuccessful.In2016,Sunset'soperationsbroughtinover$10millioninprofits.
Sunset'ssuccessisduetoaleaseagreementbetweenitselfandPointReyes.Theleaseagreement,signedonMarch1,2014,byGeorgeLambertandAlbertJones,theSecretaryoftheInterior,allowedSunsettolease200acresofPointReyestooperateanoysterprocessingplant.TheleaseagreementallowedSunsettoleasethislandatalowrateforaperiodoffouryears(untilMarch1,2018),afterwhichthelandwouldrevertbacktoPointReyesforestablishmentofamarinewildernessarea.TheleaseagreementwastobenefitnotonlySunsetandPointReyesbutalsothelocalcommunity.Theleasehelpedtocreatethousandsofjobsintheareaandrevitalizedthelocaleconomy.
However,atthetimetheleasewassignedonMarch1,2014,byMr.JonesandMr.Lambert,someverbalchangesweremadetotheleaseagreement.Specifically,Mr.JonesstatedtoMr.Lambertthefollowing:"Look,thisleaseiseconomicallybeneficialforbothofus;sowhylimititto4years?Let'sextendtheleasetermto,say,10years.Howaboutit?"Lambertagreedstating,"Sure,I'mallforit.Let'sdo10years!"Immediatelyafterthisconversation,bothmenshookhandsandsignedthelease.Buttheverbalagreementregardingthechangeintheleasetermfrom4yearsto10yearswasneverputinwriting.
FromMarch1,2014,toJanuary4,2018,thingswentwellforSunset.Itmadesubstantialprofits,peoplewereemployed,andthelocaleconomyimproved.ButinlateDecember2017,localfishermannoticedthefishanddolphinpopulationsweredying.SomelocalenvironmentalistspicketedSunset'sfacility,blamingitforthedyingfishanddolphins.However,scientistshavebeenunabletofindanyevidencelinkingSunset'soperationstothedyingfishanddolphinpopulations.
Despitelackofscientificevidence,localenvironmentalistsprotestedandtooktheircomplaintstoAlbertJones.Basedonthesecomplaints,Mr.JonesdecidedtopayasurprisevisittotheSunsetfacility.OnJanuary4,2017,Mr.JonesvisitedSunset'sfacilityinPointReyes.Withoutexplanation,heabruptlytoldMr.Lambert,"Theleaseisup,it'sover,andyou'vegot10days-untilJanuary14th-togetout."Shockedandangry,Mr.Lambertreplied,"Youcan'tdothat!Theleaseisn'tup!Wehaveacontract!"
SunsetsubsequentlyfiledsuitinSuperiorCourtagainsttheDepartmentoftheInteriorforbreachoftheleaseagreement.Inaddition,SunsetwantstoofferMr.Lambert'stestimonyincourtregardingtheverbalchangesmadetothewrittenleaseagreement.Sunsethasalsorequestedaninjunctiontostalltheclosureofitsplant.
Pleasediscusstheissuesinthiscase.
Studentdiscusses5correctissuesclearlyandconcisely
answer using the IRAC (issue, rule, application, conclusion) form
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started
