Here are the options that we are considering:

Option 1:

In order to meet your obligations to the company, decline the opportunity unless Terebro agrees to let you disclose that EG Consulting was paid by them.

Option 2:

In order to be completely honest and transparent, decline the opportunity unless Terebro agrees to include a statement on the report that EG Consulting and the engineers were paid by them.

Option 3:

Accept the contract and write the report so that the problems with the data are obvious to a skilled reader in order to get the information across without disrupting the contract.

Option 4:

In order to minimize conflict, accept the contract without restrictions and let the people reading the report come to their own conclusions.

Option 5:

In order to create the best data possible, decline the opportunity unless Terebro agrees to let you use other responsible data to prepare your report.

Option 6:

Accept the contract and send an anonymous message to an environmental group disclosing the problem because you must take control to do what's right.

Which option best meets each stakeholder's ethical desires?

You, Economics Consultant 1. You are able to prepare the report using the tools of analysis that are the hallmark of an excellent economist. 2. You are able to land important contracts that will showcase your skill and contribute to the community.

------ Options ------ 1 2 3 4 5 6

Rick Vahn and the business leaders of Terebro Energy Company, your client 1. They have an external consultant with whom they can work effectively. 2. They have a strong position paper to present to the Legislature.

------ Options ------ 1 2 3 4 5 6

Gregor Orsen, CEO of EG Consulting, your employer 1. You are able to land contracts that contribute to the bottom line as well as the reputation of the company. 2. You are able to meet the needs of your clients.

------ Options ------ 1 2 3 4 5 6

Members of the State Legislature, who will be using your report 1. They can craft a policy that meets the needs of the citizens, the employers, and the environment. 2. They have accurate information on which to base a policy decision.

------ Options ------ 1 2 3 4 5 6

Citizens of your state, who rely on your research 1. They can understand what you have written so they can have an informed opinion. 2. You disclose any conflict of interest so they can accurately judge the impartiality of your research.

------ Options ------ 1 2 3 4 5 6

Shareholders of Terebro Energy Company 1. Business decisions are made so that neither unnecessary legal risks nor financial burdens are created for the company. 2. The company's energy exploration activities increase profits and reputation.

------ Options ------ 1 2 3 4 5 6