Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

Mr Ellis lives in rural Vistoria.His property is off the electricity grid and has no independent source of power. On22 October 2012, he signed a

Mr Ellis lives in rural Vistoria.His property is off the electricity grid and has no independent source of power. On22 October 2012, he signed a purchase agreement with Bailey Engineering Pty Ltd for a 3.6kW hybrid power system. The model of the system was Firefly CYGNUS 3.6. He dealt with Mr Bailey, director of a wind turbine and solar panels. The purchase price of $19,800 included full installation. Mr Ellis paid a deposit of $11,900. The balance of $7,900 was to be paid when the installation completed, and the system generated power as intended Mr Elliis is a farmer and that was the first time he bought a hybrid power system.

In the meeting on 20 October 2012, Mr Ellis told Mr Bailey that the batteries must be made in Germany and the system must be able to charge up to and maintain at least 220voltage. Mr Bailey assured that "Yes, sure. We are producing and selling the best hybrid power systems in Australia. The batteries installed in the Firefly CYGNUS 3.6 system are mad by Bosch Germany. The system is able to charge up to and maintain at least at 220voltage". During that meeting, Mr Bailey also stated that "if you buy the system, the company will provide you with ten Philip Energy Efficient Light Bulbs". Mr Ellis responded that "Wonderful. It means I can save a lot of energy". The written contract between the parties only mentioned the parties' names. the model, the price, and the payment method.

THe footnote number five in the agreement contained a clause stating that "The batteries installed in the system are supplied by Bosch Germany. Thus, Bailey Engineering Pty Ltd will not be responsible for their functioning as wll as any damage caused by them". Singe Mr Ellis did not read the footnotes in the agreement, he was not aware of that clause when he signed the agreement. One day before the meeting to sign the contract, Mr Ellis received an email from Mr Bailey. The email was entitled "Advice on Maintenance". Apart from the detailed information regarding the way the system should be maintained, the last lines of the email also stated that " The batteries installed in the system are supplied by Bosch Germany. Thus, Bailey Engineering Pry Ltd will not be responsible for their functioning as well as any damage caused by them". Mr Ellis opened the email but read it in hurry and thus missed the statement in the last lines of the email. The receipt of the deposit also contained the same statement. However, it was not clear whether Mt Ellis checked the receipt or not.

The hybrid power system was installed at Mr Ellis's property by Bailey Engineering staff on 23 October 2012. No Energy Efficient Light Bulbs were provided to Mr Ellis. TO reduce costs, Baliley Engineering used the batteries made in China by Amperex Technology to install in the system for Mr Ellis. When Bailey Engineering staff finished the installation, they turned the system on and left the property. The system ran for a couple of hours and then turned off by itself. Mr Ellis tried to restart the system many times but the problem persisted. During the time the system appeared running, it did not generate any power.

On 25 October 2012, Mr Ellis called Bailey Engineering to report the problem. Bailey Engineering staff came and discovered that the batteries malfunctioned and did not charge sufficiently to generate power. Specifically, it was a 220voltage system, if the battery charge dropped to 200voltage it would shut off. After being informed of the problem and is caused, Mr Bailey called Mr Ellis and told him that "if you pay extra $5000, we will change the batteries and make the system work for you". Mr Ellis was in need of power and thus he agreed to that requirement.

Since it was a very cold winter and Mr Ellis urgently needed power to run the heater, on 27 October 2012 he went to Home Depot to buy a portable petrol generator. The store had only one portable generator left. That was an EG3600CX generator, and it had been used by the store as a demonstration model. Mr Ellis was interested in the EG3600CX generator and he asked the salesman: "Is that for sale?" The sales man responded that "No. It is for demonstration only, but I will check with my boss". After talking to his boss, the salesperson told Mr Ellis that "we can sell it to you for $4000. we can deliver it to your property and you can pay upon delivery". Mr Ellis told the saleperson that "can you keep it for me for two days? I need some more tiems to think about whether it is the right generator for my property". The saleperson agreed. When Mr Ellis left the store, another customer came and wated to buy the EX3600CX generator for $5000. Home Depot immediately sold the generator to that customer. On 29 October 2012, Mr Ellis called the salemand at Home Depot and told him that "I accept your offer . Please deliver the generator to my property at 65 James Street, Red Hill. I will pay $4000 upon delivery". After hearing that, the salesman told Mr Ellis that the generator was already sold. Mr Ellis was very unhappy. He insisted that the store must deliver the generator to him.

On 7 November 2012,the batteries of the hybrid power system would work properly, he still wanted to have a petrol generator as a backup. He called Home Depot and told them that "Please deliver the generator to me. If you don't do that,I will sue you". The salesman at Home Depot responded that "I am sorry. We have no portable generator left to deliver to you"

The hybrid power system worked for five days but then the batteries overheated and exploded, destroying the entire roof of Mr Ellis's house. Mr Ellis had to spend $30,000 to repair his house. During the time the system worked, the batteries can be charged up to 210 voltage only. Being frustrated with the problems, Mr Ellis refused to pay Bailey Engineering the remaining of $7,900 and the $5000.

Discuss all relevant issues in relation to who can sue whom for what?

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access with AI-Powered Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image

Step: 3

blur-text-image

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

Applied Regression Analysis And Other Multivariable Methods

Authors: David G. Kleinbaum, Lawrence L. Kupper, Azhar Nizam, Eli S. Rosenberg

5th Edition

1285051084, 978-1285963754, 128596375X, 978-1285051086

Students also viewed these Law questions