Please see attached and answer the following questions. The questions are from Assignment 3.

Is this argument formally valid? Experts agree that introducing a carbon tax would reduce emissions. Therefore, introducing a carbon tax would reduce emissions. O Not formally valid O Formally valid Question 10 Is this argument formally valid? Experts agree that introducing a carbon tax would reduce emissions. If experts agree that introducing a carbon tax would reduce emissions, then introducing a carbon tax would not reduce emissions. Therefore, introducing a carbon tax would not reduce emissions. O Formally valid O Not formally valid