Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Question
1 Approved Answer
Read the below work and comment and open for discussion. Analysis of Inequalities Using John Rawls' Principles. First Principle: Equal Liberty. Application to Tech Billionaires
Read the below work and comment and open for discussion.
Analysis of Inequalities Using John Rawls' Principles.
First Principle: Equal Liberty. Application to Tech Billionaires and Child Labour: Rawls' first principle of justice emphasizes that each person should have an equal right to the most extensive basic liberties compatible with similar liberties for others.
In the context of tech billionaires and cobalt mining, while the billionaires enjoy extensive liberties and rights to pursue economic gains, the children in the DRC mining cobalt often lack basic rights and freedoms. They are forced into labor, deprived of education, and exposed to hazardous conditions, which starkly contrasts with the liberties enjoyed by the wealthy tech entrepreneurs.
Second Principle: Difference Principle and Fair Equality of Opportunity. Fair Equality of Opportunity: This aspect of Rawls' second principle demands that everyone should have a fair chance to attain various offices and positions. In our case, the children working in cobalt mines have significantly fewer opportunities for education and personal development compared to the affluent in technologically advanced societies. This disparity in opportunity violates the principle of fair equality of opportunity.
Difference Principle: Rawls argues that social and economic inequalities are to be arranged so that they are to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged. The current scenario, where tech billionaires amass wealth partly through the exploitation of vulnerable child laborers, does not benefit the least advantaged the child laborers Instead, it exacerbates their poverty and misery.
Analysis Using the Veil of IgnoranceThe veil of ignorance is a method of determining the morality of issues by considering the perspectives of all parties without knowing one's own status. Applying this to our case: Under the veil of ignorance, one would not know if they would be born as a tech billionaire or a child laborer in the DRC This uncertainty would likely lead to the creation of a societal structure that does not excessively favor one group over another. From this perspective, the existing stark inequality would be deemed unjust, as the benefits and burdens of economic activity are not distributed fairly. A more equitable distribution of wealth and opportunities would likely be the outcome of decisionmaking under the veil of ignorance.
Personal Opinion on the InequalityI believe that the described inequality is not acceptable. It is fundamentally unjust for the immense wealth of a few to be built on the back of severe poverty and exploitation of many, especially when it involves vulnerable populations such as children.
Rationale for Opinion Moral and Ethical Grounds: Exploiting the most vulnerable, like child laborers in the DRC for the sake of profit and luxury for a few goes against basic ethical principles of fairness and human dignity. Sustainability and Longterm Viability: An economic system that relies on such stark inequalities is not sustainable in the long run. It fosters social unrest, hinders development in impoverished regions, and creates an unstable global economy. Human Rights Perspective: Every individual, regardless of their birthplace or economic status, deserves to live with dignity, have access to education, and the opportunity to pursue a fulfilling life. The current scenario undermines these basic human rights.In conclusion, the link between the wealth of tech billionaires and the poverty and exploitation in cobalt mining, as seen through the lens of John Rawls' principles and the veil of ignorance, is ethically and morally untenable
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started