Theory Summarization Paper DUE Week of February $12$

Rubric for INFS$6215$ Assignment Assessment

Explicitly related to information system technology literature and$/$or theory

$1$

Not related, not empirical, little or no theory

$2$

Could be appropriate subject but insufficient theory detail published

$3$

OK topic but incomplete$$elaboration and inclusion of theory discussion

$4$

Appropriate discussion and inclusion of theory with sufficient depth for analysis

Organized clearly, a logically$,$ and consistently

$1$

Not organized

$2$

Some organization

$3$

Organized but not logically progressive

$4$

Well organized

Clearly defined introduction and summary$/$conclusion

$1$

Not Included

$2$

Introduction and$/$or conclusion not consistent with body of paper

$3$

Introduction or conclusion ok but weak, wordy or awkward

$4$

Well done

Writing Style and Development of ideas; persuasiveness of argument

$1$

Some ideas stated, but mostly unsupported

$2$

Few ideas stated, but not persuasive

$3$

Good ideas but not developed well

$4$

Good ideas and strong development; persuasive

Scholarship$$Supportive with citations from the literature and$/$or data.

$1$

Opinion $--$unsubstantiated

$2$

Few or inappropriate citations

$3$

Appropriate for the most part

$4$

Well done

Analysis

$1$

No analysis at all

$2$

Very little analysis

$3$

Some analysis, but not developed well

$4$

Good analysis

Synthesis of multiple ideas$/$concepts

$1$

No synthesis at all

$2$

Very little synthesis

$3$

Some synthesis, but not developed well

$4$

Good synthesis

Met Objectives of the Assignment

$1$

Not met

$2$

Partially met

$3$

Met some of the objectives

$4$

Met all the objectives