These words would imply or be reasonably understood as meaning that the plaintiff was an amphibian rather than a human being. In that regard, it is appropriate, in the judge's View, to recall what Lord Selbome LC said in The Capital and Counties Bank, Limited V George Henty & Sons (1882) 7 App Gas 741 at p 745: The test, according to the authorities, is, whether under the circumstances in which the writing was published, reasonable men, to whom the publication was made, would be likely to understand it in a libelous sense. The court's final decision as to the rights of the parties, the court's response to a party's request for relief. Generally, the appellate court will either affirm, reverse, or reverse with instructions