Use these articles to answer the following question. Answer for all 4 articles.

1.Fama EF,French KR, 2015A five-factor asset pricing model, Journal of Financial Economics, 116 :1-22

2.Nikbakht E, Sarkar S, Spieler AC, 2017 External monitoring of private firms: A cross-country empirical analysis, Global Finance Journal, 32 :113-127

3.Turtle HJ, Wang K 2017 The value in Fundamental Accounting Information, The Journal of Financial Research 40(1) :113-140

4.Buschman rd and Sjoquist dl, 2016 An Exploration of Differential State Responses to Changes in Fiscal Conditions, Public Budgeting & Finance: 47-76

Critique each of the above articles as though you are a reviewer for the journal based on the following criteria. Also comment on how well the article fares on each criterion:

Originality

How original is the topic covered in the article? Is there anything new that has not yet been published before?

Significance

How significant is the article to the industry? Would anyone get any value out of reading the article?

Technical quality

How sophisticated is the content of the article? is the information communicated in an understandable manner without insulting the intelligence of the intended audiance?

Relevance

How relevant is the article to the conference/journal? How dies it fit into the theme of the conference/journal?

Presentation

How good is the quality of the rticle (i.e. the layout, graphs, diagrams etc) are the diagrams readable and do they contribute towards understanding the content of the article?

Advice

What advice would you give the author of each of the above articles to improve the article.

Future articles

State what future research you would recommend for another article.