Suppose that instead of not presenting Leslie’s alternative at all, you present it, but in a very negative light. You are honest when you focus the bulk of your description of it on disadvantages, because that’s what you believe. However, you also know that Leslie does not agree with the way you see the situation. Given your biased presentation, the committee selects your alternative.

a. According to Kant’s categorical imperative, is your behavior ethical?

b. According to utilitarianism, is your behavior ethical?