Criteria	Weight	Proposal A	Proposal B	Proposal C
C1. Technical approach
C2. Management approach
C3. Past performance
C4. Price

The criteria weights were to be determined from the consistent judgments:

C1=3C2, C2=5C3, C3=0.6C4

The measures of the proposals based on criteria were to be determined from the inconsistent judgments:

For C1,Technical approach: A=3.0B, B=0.1C, A=2.0C

For C2,Management approach: A=2.0B, B=0.5C, A=0.8C

For C3,Past performance: A=2.0B, B=0.1C, A=1.5C

For C4,Price: A=3.0B, B=0.2C, A=0.8C

1. Which criteria has the highest weight?

A. Technical approach B. Management approach C. Past performance D. Price

2. Which proposal has the highest score for the criterion with the highest weight?

A. Proposal A B. Proposal B C. Proposal C

3. Which proposal has the highest score for the criterion with the lowest weight?

A. Proposal A B. Proposal B C. Proposal C

4. Which proposal will never win regardless of the weights

based on unbiased weighted scores? A B C

5. If the criteria are equally weighted, which proposal wins

based on unbiased equally weighted scores? A B C

6. Which proposal wins based on unbiased weighted scores? A B C