Dilpreet hires Ash's sister Karen as a dancer to entertain patrons at Dilpreet's restaurant. Karen urges Bob, a customer who is celebrating his 60th birthday with his family, to join her in a dance. Bob had been drinking some alcohol but later claims he was not drunk. While vigorously attempting to keep up with Karen, Bob breaks his hip. This has never happened at Dilpreet's restaurant before and it has never happened to Karen either. Bob had no previous history of hip problems.

Does Bob have an action against Karen in the tort of negligence? What defence arguments may be used in this scenario? Use relevant cases to support your answers. Using Issue, rule , application Conclusion