How did the preparations for the Popes visit make visible for Emily Riddle who is deemed important
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
- How did the preparations for the Pope’s visit make visible for Emily Riddle who is deemed important and valuable, and who isn’t?
![student submitted image, transcription available below](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/questions/2023/10/6536021999c03_1698038296527.jpg)
![student submitted image, transcription available below](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/questions/2023/10/6536021953eba_1698038296179.jpg)
![were downtown that week to remove largely houseless Indigenous folks who are Survivors or intergenerational](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/questions/2023/10/6536025873ade_1698038359959.jpg)
Transcribed Image Text:
Kelsi: I want to start by discussing the intent behind the apology. The Pope's apology to residential school Survivors, their families, and communities is #58 of the TRC Calls to Action. Why do you think Survivors made this a Call to Action? Why is it important? Emily Riddle: I think the reason why apologies are important mostly stems from our cultures. For us, in our Cree culture, apologies and words are really powerful. That comes from the power that stems from our language, too, and how sounds reverberate in the universe, which itself, we believe, is made of sound. Apologies are also really powerful to speak into the universe because they communicate intentions. While I think that there's a lot of criticism of apologies being meaningless, there is a cultural importance of apology, as well as active witnessing. With all of this in mind, do you feel like the intent and importance behind the apology was sufficiently expressed by the Pope? I feel like we have to separate the Pope from the structure of the Catholic Church to an extent. I think for the Pope, it was a genuine apology. When he was on the plane back to Italy, reporters asked him why he didn't include the word "genocide" in his apology, and he said, "Oh, certainly it was a genocide." I know this trip was not viewed favourably within the Church. It was something that this specific Pope really pushed for. And while the actual apology itself was powerful, it was limited, too. For one thing, he implies there were a few bad apples in the Catholic Church that made this system bad. He repeats this sentiment in Lac Ste. Anne: Christian charity was not absent, although a few people misbehaved. So I think the Pope did feel his apology, individually, but I don't think that the church understands how they're part of this system of dispossession. This system has resulted in the continued removal of children, poverty, and us being alienated from our territories. And a part of this larger system of colonialism that the Catholic Church obviously still plays a role in is seen with doctrines and Papal bulls. I don't think that the apology addresses that. The Church has committed to a report and an investigation, but I don't see a commitment to try to tear down the system they helped build or to give us some of their money or land they continue to own. I say that because we've already seen the Canadian branch of the Catholic Church failing to pay the $25 million it already owes to residential school Survivors, instead raising less than $4 million dollars. Can't the Vatican implore their Canadian arm to actually pay those funds? It is all in very bad taste. People think that Indigenous people are into settlements or money all the time, too. But for us, money is a part of a protocol. Gifting is very important; it's about the relationship and the cultural protocol of making an offering. Despite the limitations, do you think the Call to Action can be considered complete? The apology required a lot of advocacy by Indigenous folks over a number of years. I really respect the people who worked to bring the Pope here, such as Chief Wilton Littlechild and other community members. A lot of people expressed disagreement with the Pope's visit, but it was an intentional invitation by Indigenous community members and leaders. The fact that the Pope did come and make an apology does deserve some credit, at least for those who fought for it. But I know you mentioned that Yellowhead is not including Call to Action 58 as fully complete. Kelsi: I want to start by discussing the intent behind the apology. The Pope's apology to residential school Survivors, their families, and communities is #58 of the TRC Calls to Action. Why do you think Survivors made this a Call to Action? Why is it important? Emily Riddle: I think the reason why apologies are important mostly stems from our cultures. For us, in our Cree culture, apologies and words are really powerful. That comes from the power that stems from our language, too, and how sounds reverberate in the universe, which itself, we believe, is made of sound. Apologies are also really powerful to speak into the universe because they communicate intentions. While I think that there's a lot of criticism of apologies being meaningless, there is a cultural importance of apology, as well as active witnessing. With all of this in mind, do you feel like the intent and importance behind the apology was sufficiently expressed by the Pope? I feel like we have to separate the Pope from the structure of the Catholic Church to an extent. I think for the Pope, it was a genuine apology. When he was on the plane back to Italy, reporters asked him why he didn't include the word "genocide" in his apology, and he said, "Oh, certainly it was a genocide." I know this trip was not viewed favourably within the Church. It was something that this specific Pope really pushed for. And while the actual apology itself was powerful, it was limited, too. For one thing, he implies there were a few bad apples in the Catholic Church that made this system bad. He repeats this sentiment in Lac Ste. Anne: Christian charity was not absent, although a few people misbehaved. So I think the Pope did feel his apology, individually, but I don't think that the church understands how they're part of this system of dispossession. This system has resulted in the continued removal of children, poverty, and us being alienated from our territories. And a part of this larger system of colonialism that the Catholic Church obviously still plays a role in is seen with doctrines and Papal bulls. I don't think that the apology addresses that. The Church has committed to a report and an investigation, but I don't see a commitment to try to tear down the system they helped build or to give us some of their money or land they continue to own. I say that because we've already seen the Canadian branch of the Catholic Church failing to pay the $25 million it already owes to residential school Survivors, instead raising less than $4 million dollars. Can't the Vatican implore their Canadian arm to actually pay those funds? It is all in very bad taste. People think that Indigenous people are into settlements or money all the time, too. But for us, money is a part of a protocol. Gifting is very important; it's about the relationship and the cultural protocol of making an offering. Despite the limitations, do you think the Call to Action can be considered complete? The apology required a lot of advocacy by Indigenous folks over a number of years. I really respect the people who worked to bring the Pope here, such as Chief Wilton Littlechild and other community members. A lot of people expressed disagreement with the Pope's visit, but it was an intentional invitation by Indigenous community members and leaders. The fact that the Pope did come and make an apology does deserve some credit, at least for those who fought for it. But I know you mentioned that Yellowhead is not including Call to Action 58 as fully complete.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
The preparations for the Popes visit made visible for Emily Riddle who is deemed important and valua... View the full answer
Related Book For
Auditing A Practical Approach
ISBN: 9780730382645
4th Edition
Authors: Robyn Moroney, Fiona Campbell, Jane Hamilton
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
Case analysis is a multi - step process. This exercise will help you to learn to analyze a case by framing questions, labeling variables, synthesizing information, summarizing facts, and drawing...
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Now that you have background on ethics and a set of skills for evaluating ethical issues, the application to real-life dilemmas seems fairly straightforward. However, there is one additional aspect...
-
A woman is 5'6" and 150 lbs. pre-pregnancy. Calculate the healthy weight range (lowest to highest) you expect to see just prior to delivery. Include all math to show how you found the answer. A woman...
-
Find the distance between each pair of points. a. (2, 5) and (8, 13) b. (0, 3) and (5, 10) c. (- 4, 6) and (- 2, - 3) d. (3, d) and (- 6, 3d)
-
Graph the function y = (x + |x|). At what values of x does the derivative exist and what is the value of the derivative when it does exist?
-
At December 31, 2001, Los Alamos Corporation reported these plant assets: Instructions (a) Journalize the transactions. [Hint: You may wish to set up T accounts, post beginning balances, and then...
-
On January 2, 2014, MacCloud Co. issued a 4-year, $100,000 note at 6% fixed interest, interest payable semiannually. MacCloud now wants to change the note to a variable-rate note. As a result, on...
-
A marching band performs on the football field at half-time. As they perform, the members of the band stand in the shape of a sinusoidal function. While playing, they move, but still maintain the...
-
Complete the "Rate Category" column on the "Airline" worksheet. After completing the column do exploratory analysis of the airline data to determine how many Airlines fall under Category A ? Use the...
-
Buhlle Company (Pty) Ltd has put together the following data in order to complete their operating budget for the second quarter of 2019: April MayJuneJuly Sales (units)732006890065400 67300...
-
Considering the strategic implementation phases in the planning phase and bringing forward this in the context of leadership, critically discuss how you would approach complexity, culture and...
-
what are the role and responsibilities of the team leader? how are they different from first-line managers?
-
Consider various independent and collaborative roles that promote effective teamwork (e.g., facilitator, participant, collaborator, leader, employee, manager, assistant, mentee, mentor). What are...
-
Give an example of a critical business process then explain the following: Identify 3 measures of the process. Identify a direct measure of process capability. Identify 3 sources of common cause...
-
2) List the methods of payment in the order of security. Explain how the role of banks differ under different payment methods.
-
help please A bacteria culture starts with 340 bacteria and grows at a rate proportional to its size. After 2 hours there will be 680 bacteria. (a) Express the population P after t hours as a...
-
What is your assessment of the negotiations process, given what you have studied? What are your recommendations for Mr. Reed? You must justify your conclusions
-
Discuss the usefulness of examining subsequent payments as an evidence-gathering technique. If an auditor was to use this technique, what would they be looking for?
-
If preliminary testing of controls reveals that the rate of deviation in controls is above the expected rate, the auditor will: (a) Reduce detection risk and increase reliance on detailed substantive...
-
Donna Angelo is designing the audit program for cash for her client, Northerly Aspect Ltd (Northerly Aspect). Northerly Aspect is a property management services company. It deals with six major...
-
Advanced: Evaluation of projects with unequal lives A2Z p.l.c. supports the concept of terotechnology or life cycle costing for new investment decisions covering its engineering activities. The...
-
Advanced: Relevant cash flows and taxation plus unequal lives Pavgrange pic is considering expanding its opera tions. The company accountant has produced pro forma profit and loss accounts for the...
-
Advanced: Inflation adjustments and sensitivity analysis (a) Burley pic, a manufacturer of building products, mainly supplies the wholesale trade. It has recently suffered falling demand due to...
![Mobile App Logo](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/includes/images/mobile/finalLogo.png)
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App