Instructions for reviewer. Type your comments directly beneath the rating for each category. For example, in the Purpose & Validity or Relevance row, if you believe the paper is of publishable quality, type in either an X or check mark noting the specific criteria in the column for Publishable Quality. Extended comments can be written at the end in the area provided for comments. Save the file with your full name and submit for grading. Title of article Purpose & Validity or Relevance Comments: Content Comments: Readability & Organization Comments: Tables, charts and graphs if any used Comments: Grammar and formatting (spelling, punctuation, capitalization, etc.) Comments: Recommendation Overall Comments: Publishable quality (Very Good to Excellent) The topic is relevant to the purpose and overarching theme of the e-zine in the context of business and business education Information and narrative provides reasonable support for a central purpose or argument and displays evidence of a basic analysis of an important topic. Reader gains some insights. Article reads like a professional article in organization of ideas and word choices; thesis is clear up-front & well- articulated Information is organized with well-constructed paragraphs. The ideas are arranged logically to support the central purpose or argument. Assist in explaining data or results. No errors in grammar or format relative to length and complexity, or few (