Question
Police officer Summer Winter arrested Elvis Greaseley on a burglary charge. Officer Winter neglected to give Greaseley the Miranda warnings at the time of the
Police officer Summer Winter arrested Elvis Greaseley on a burglary charge. Officer
Winter neglected to give Greaseley the Miranda warnings at the time of the arrest or at any time
thereafter. During "booking" at the police station, Officer Winter required an unwilling Greaseley
to submit to fingerprinting. (Information obtained through the fingerprinting process ultimately
proved useful, because the police discovered Greaseley's fingerprints on the glass door of the
store where the burglary occurred.) After booking was completed, Detective Springer Fall
interrogated Greaseley at the police station. Detective Fall did not give Greaseley the Miranda
warnings because he (Detective Fall) erroneously assumed that Officer Winter had already done
so. In fact, however, Officer Winter had not done so. During the course of the interrogation by
Detective Fall, Greaseley confessed to the burglary for which he had been arrested. Greaseley
later retained attorney Priscilla Lisamarie to represent him in the burglary case. She has filed, on
Greaseley's behalf, a motion to suppress (i.e., motion requesting a court order excluding certain
evidence) in which she argues that the fingerprinting of Greaseley and the interrogation of him
violated his Fifth Amendment rights and his Miranda rights. Lisamarie argues, therefore, that the
exclusionary rule should be applied, so as to prevent the state from using the following evidence
against Greaseley: (A) any evidence derived from the fingerprinting that took place during
booking; and (B) Greaseley's confession. Is Lisamarie correct in her argument that Greaseley's
Fifth Amendment rights and Miranda rights were violated? Why or why not? As to the evidence
(listed above as (A) and (B) ) mentioned in the motion to suppress, state whether the
exclusionary rule would prevent the prosecution from using that evidence against Greaseley. Explain you reasoning
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started