SummarizeFor Ohio State football fans, one of the biggest questions from the last three years is: How can the Buckeyes keep beating Michigan on signing day, and losing on game day? "I point this out to Buckeye fans they're beating us with players we didn't want," said Mark Porter, the founder of the high school football recruiting website ScoutingOhio.com. To Porter, the reason is simple: Even the best coaches and recruiters get it wrong half the time, meaning programs that can keep the recruiting battle close (like Michigan) can close the gap once those recruits get on campus. "On signing day, you're always so proud of all these five-stars (recruits), but the reality is, half the kids in your recruiting class are technically going to be misses," said Porter, who founded his site in 2005. "All this early evaluation on kids who aren't done developing is wrong. You know the math is wrong, but you're doing the best you can with the information you have. That's true of the NFL, too. While college coaches have the difficult task of projecting what a 16- or 17-year-old will become when he's 22, NFL scouts (seemingly) have the easier task of projecting